Cast Iron Grills Review


Our review process

Ever consider how you can enhance your next BBQ? There are many options of grills to choose. How do you know which grill is the best for your cooking needs? Luckily, our team spent countless hours compiling, researching, and evaluating over 1,300 grills, each one having 89 data specifications. During our time reviewing each grill, we found four that are cast iron grills. Our end goal is to provide you with effective information so that you can find the best grill for your home. We took into account first-hand user reviews and included key features, such as dimensions and body construction material. Therefore, we are excited to show you the following guide that will review some of the advantages and disadvantages in order to assist you in finding the grill of your dreams!

We've reviewed cast iron grills and wanted to share some of our insights with you. Cast iron grills have flame-resistant technology, protecting against the damaging effects heat can cause. They have superior resistance to corrosion for everyday use. Designed to keep the surface at a proper cooking temperature for extended periods of time, they feature excellent heat retention, so they can remain hot for longer. However, they require more maintenance than other types of grills, so they take more time and work to clean. Moreover, cast iron grates tend to rust easily, but this can be prevented to a certain extent if you don't keep them outside and always dry them right after you wash them.

Our Top Ranking Grills:
Product NameBrandFuel TypeCooking Grate MaterialCooking AreaGrill Type
Best Overall Score
1
An image of Weber 44020001 Liquid Propane Cast Iron Grill
Weber 44020001 Liquid Propane Cast Iron Grill
Weber
liquid propane
porcelain-enameled cast iron
450 sq. in.
Runner Up
2
An image of Pit Boss 72820 Deluxe Wood Pellet Cast Iron Freestanding Barrel Grill
Pit Boss 72820 Deluxe Wood Pellet Cast Iron Freestanding Barrel Grill
Pit Boss
wood pellet
cast iron
820 sq. in.
barrel grill
Best Affordable Option
3
An image of Char-Griller 2137 Outlaw Charcoal Cast Iron Freestanding Barrel Grill
Char-Griller 2137 Outlaw Charcoal Cast Iron Freestanding Barrel Grill
Char-Griller
charcoal
cast iron
1060 sq. in.
barrel grill
Best Portable Grill
4
An image of Char-Griller 06614 Akorn Charcoal Cast Iron Portable Kamado Grill
Char-Griller 06614 Akorn Charcoal Cast Iron Portable Kamado Grill
Char-Griller
charcoal
cast iron
153 sq. in.
vessel/kamado grill
Best for BBQs
5
An image of Camp Chef YK60LWC12 Propane Gas Cast Iron Freestanding Open Grill
Camp Chef YK60LWC12 Propane Gas Cast Iron Freestanding Open Grill
Camp Chef
propane gas
cast iron
448 sq. in.
open grill
Our Top Ranking Grills
Customer Rating
Brand
Weber
Fuel Type
liquid propane
Cooking Grate Material
porcelain-enameled cast iron
Cooking Area
450 sq. in.
Grill Type
Customer Rating
Brand
Pit Boss
Fuel Type
wood pellet
Cooking Grate Material
cast iron
Cooking Area
820 sq. in.
Grill Type
barrel grill
Customer Rating
Brand
Char-Griller
Fuel Type
charcoal
Cooking Grate Material
cast iron
Cooking Area
1060 sq. in.
Grill Type
barrel grill
Customer Rating
Brand
Char-Griller
Fuel Type
charcoal
Cooking Grate Material
cast iron
Cooking Area
153 sq. in.
Grill Type
vessel/kamado grill
Customer Rating
Brand
Camp Chef
Fuel Type
propane gas
Cooking Grate Material
cast iron
Cooking Area
448 sq. in.
Grill Type
open grill
Best Overall Score
An image of Weber 44020001 Liquid Propane Cast Iron Grill

The Weber Liquid Propane Grill features a GS4™ High Performance Grilling System and is designed with two burners, letting you utilize the indirect and direct heat necessary for two-zone cooking. This cast iron grill features porcelain-enameled Flavorizer® bars to keep oil and grease from reaching the burners. It has a GS4 grilling system, which uses a Genesis II LX All-Grill igniter that will start the grill and adjust the temperature with just one control button.

    Pros
    • Features an Infinity™ ignition, allowing you to quickly start up your barbecue
    • Warming rack helps keep food hot
    • GS4 grilling system uses a Genesis II LX All-Grill igniter that will ignite the grill and adjust the overall temperature with just one control button
    Cons
    • Cast iron construction has a much bulkier structure than stainless steel
    • Porcelain-enameled cast iron cooking grate causes rust and tarnishing much easier than stainless steel or normal cast iron
    • Infinity™ ignition loses its ability to work very quickly if it gets too dirty
Runner Up
An image of Pit Boss 72820 Deluxe Wood Pellet Cast Iron Freestanding Barrel Grill

Count on the Pit Boss Deluxe Wood Pellet Barrel Grill for a delicious barbecue experience you can share with your family and friends. This electronically ignited wood pellet grill is designed to make lighting your wood pellet grill as easy as possible with a simple push of a button. This cast iron grill features a freestanding design, which saves space, giving you greater flexibility in your outdoor dining space. Equipped with a smoker add-on, it is perfect for adding extra flavor to whatever you're cooking. It uses wood pellets for various cooking options, including smoking, roasting, or braising meat to your personal preferences. It has a cast iron cooking grate, which supplies a dependable surface that will last a long time.

    Pros
    • Electronic ignition makes lighting your wood pellet grill quick and simple
    • Smoker add-on gives your meat a smoky, slow-cooked taste
    • Uses wood pellets, offering a variety of cooking styles smoke, roast, or braise meat to your personal preferences
    Cons
    • Cast iron design has a much heavier structure than stainless steel
    • Features a cast iron grill grate, requiring constant oiling to stop corrosion
    • Electronic ignition loses its ability to work very fast if it gets too dirty
Best Affordable Option
An image of Char-Griller 2137 Outlaw Charcoal Cast Iron Freestanding Barrel Grill

For the ideal combination of performance and practicality, use the Char-Griller Outlaw Charcoal Barrel Grill. Featuring a warming rack, this cast iron grill is perfect for keeping food from getting cold. It has a temperature gauge, so you can always monitor the temperature of the grill in order to achieve perfect results each and every time. Quickly and easily get rid of ashes accumulated while cooking with its easy-dump ash pan. This cast iron grill features a freestanding design, allowing you to move it out of the way to save space when it's not in use. Fueled by charcoal, it allows you to easily control the temperature, ensuring tender results each and every time. It has a cast iron cooking grate, supplying a high-quality non-stick surface that you can rely on for a long time. This cast iron grill has three shelves to offer extra working space.

    Pros
    • Warming rack helps keep your food warm
    • Features a storage rack, providing ample storage space for conveniently tucking away all your tools and utensils
    • Uses charcoal, barbecuing the meat to give it an excellent smoky flavor
    Cons
    • Cast iron construction has a much heavier structure than stainless steel
    • Includes a cast iron grill grate, taking a considerable amount of time to heat up
    • Charcoal gets dirty and tougher to clean
Best Portable Grill
An image of Char-Griller 06614 Akorn Charcoal Cast Iron Portable Kamado Grill

If you're a person who takes delight in backyard barbecues, the Char-Griller Akorn Charcoal Vessel/kamado Grill is the grill for you. Control the level of heat with this kamado grill's adjustable air vents. It has a portable design, so you can conveniently take it camping or to a friend's house. Fueled by charcoal, it grills the meat and infuses a deep, smoky flavor. This kamado grill includes a cast iron cooking grate, providing a high-quality non-stick surface that you can rely on for a long time.

    Pros
    • Grease pan collects grease from your food and prevents it from damaging the grill
    • Charcoal cooks your food for a long period of time to ensure the meat remains soft for an authentic barbecue experience
    • Fitted with adjustable air vents to control the temperature within your grill
    Cons
    • Cast iron construction has a much bulkier structure than stainless steel
    • Features a cast iron cooking grate, taking a considerable amount of time to get hot
    • Charcoal is difficult to use during colder seasons because it requires more time to get to its ideal cooking temperature
Best for BBQs
An image of Camp Chef YK60LWC12 Propane Gas Cast Iron Freestanding Open Grill

The Camp Chef Propane Gas Open Grill is a superb addition to any backyard. This Camp Chef grill has an electronic ignition to take the struggle out of starting your grill. It features a cast iron grill grate, providing a dependable cooking surface that you can rely on for a long time. Fueled by propane gas, it distributes heat evenly across the grill to ensure consistent results every time. Equipped with a freestanding design, this cast iron grill provides greater freedom and flexibility in your outdoor cooking area. It features two burners, letting you utilize the direct and indirect heat necessary for two-zone cooking.

    Pros
    • Electronic ignition makes lighting your propane gas grill quick and simple
    • Propane gas locks in juices to ensure tender and flavorful results
    • Features a freestanding design, giving you the freedom and flexibility to roll it out of the way while you are using your outdoor deck
    Cons
    • Conventional burners take much longer than infrared burners to cook your food
    • Cast iron construction has a much heavier structure than stainless steel
    • Includes a cast iron grill grate, taking a long time to heat up
Searching for the Perfect Cast Iron Grill for You:
Which Is the Ultimate Grill Type for Your Cast Iron Grill?
Kamado Grills

If you want a grill that does both smoking and grilling, a kamado grill might be what you need. Have a look at this cast iron grill might be the perfect option. These kamado grills have ventilated heat regulation so that you can cook food at a precise temperature without it overcooking or burning. They preserve flavor and moisture due to the frequent rotation of the grill's interior, grilling only the best results. Designed to absorb heat for an extended period, they are built with ceramic materials, so you can easily control and maintain the required temperature for cooking.

Open Grills

Think that open grills are right for you? Then check out this cast iron grill after you finish reading about them. These open grills have ventilated heat regulation, ensuring a safe and secure level of airflow. They circulate heat evenly, which gives for juicy, delicious results. They are generally wider than other grills, which is excellent for cooking multiple food items all at once.

Barrel Grills

The following guide will help you narrow down what to look for when considering barrel grills. You can take a look at this cast iron grill if these kinds of grills are what you're looking for. These barrel grills have ventilated heat regulation, ensuring a safe and secure level of airflow. They have an extensive surface area, so they cook large quantities of food all at once. Barrel grills have a round or oval shape, directing heat to a central area to cook food at a faster rate.

Which Cast Iron Grill Should You Be Installing?
Freestanding Grills

Debating whether to get a freestanding grill? We'll try to help you make your decision by giving you some important information that you need. These freestanding grills are particularly great for grilling novices since you don't need to commit to building an entire outdoor kitchen. They are easy to move around, allowing you to save space in your outdoor area. Freestanding grills are typically built with internal storage units to help keep all barbecuing utensils in one convenient area. They are compact, making them a space-saving option. However, they don't have any prep space, unlike built-in grills, so if you're trying to set-up an entire cooking station, they're not the ideal option. Interested in a freestanding grill? Here's one to take a look at.

Portable Grills

Interested in portable grills? Here are a few things you should know about them. Feel free to check out this great cast iron grill in the meantime. Portable grills feature a compact design, which is ideal for smaller outdoor areas. They feature internal storage units, so you can keep all cooking supplies in one easily accessible area. However, they often don't feature safety mechanisms, so if you choose to get one, it's a good idea to read up on proper use.

Understanding Fuel Types for Cast Iron Grills
Charcoal Grills

Interested in charcoal grills? Here are a few things you should know about them. Check out this great cast iron grill that we picked for you. Charcoal grills feature a slow and gradual cooking process, which ensures that meat remains tender for delicious results. They are capable of reaching 700 degrees Fahrenheit, producing a caramelized and crunchy exterior on your meat. Offering searing capabilities, they give meat exceptional flavor and create the perfect texture. They are more likely to burn off any visible fat for more nutritious dishes. However, they can take up to 25-30 minutes to heat up, resulting in a lengthier cooking process. Also, they tend to rust and build-up carbon and ash, leaving behind a lot of ash that will cause food to stick during future grilling. A benefit is that they can achieve a smoky, rich flavor, preserving a juicy flavor for all food.

Wood Pellet Grills

Want to learn more about wood pellet cast iron grills? Keep reading the following paragraph to learn more about them. Pellet grills are able to reach 700 degrees Fahrenheit, producing a caramelized and crunchy exterior on your steaks. They are built with temperature control dials, giving you precise control during the grilling process. They produce several different flavors and tastes, which will meet any pallet. Interested in a wood pellet grill? Check out this one.

Propane Gas Grills

Interested in propane gas grills? Here are a few things you should consider about them. Check out this highly-ranked cast iron grill. Propane grills are low maintenance, ensuring that they stay in great condition with little upkeep required. They are capable of reaching temperatures ranging between 400 to 600 degrees Fahrenheit, ensuring that your food is slowly cooked over just the right amount of time. They are built with temperature control knobs, giving you precise control during the grilling process. They distribute heat evenly, preventing over or under-cooked food. Designed to ensure a rapid and safe startup every time, they come with igniters, so you can grill without the use of a lighter or match. However, propane grills have wide venting, so you won't get that smoky flavor you might like. In addition, they run out of fuel after repeated use, so you'll need to have backup propane ready in order to finish cooking your food. On the other hand, propane grills contain 2,500 BTUs per cubic feet as compared to 1,000 BTUs for natural gas, contributing to faster heating.